FROM THE ALABAMA LAWYER: One of the Good Guys – Pryor becomes Chief Judge of the Eleventh Circuit

Judge William H. Pryor, Jr. became Chief Judge of the United States Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit in June 2020, making him the highest-ranking officer of his court. It’s not exactly where a young Bill Pryor thought his career would take him.

Continue ReadingFROM THE ALABAMA LAWYER: One of the Good Guys – Pryor becomes Chief Judge of the Eleventh Circuit

FROM THE ALABAMA LAWYER: Avoid Conviction Through Settlement – The Rise of Deferred Prosecution

Alabama has dramatically increased pretrial diversion programs. They now exist in criminal cases involving theft, driving under the influence (DUI), drug offenses, property offenses, traffic offense, sex offenses, domestic violence, and others. They almost all have a few common threads.

Continue ReadingFROM THE ALABAMA LAWYER: Avoid Conviction Through Settlement – The Rise of Deferred Prosecution

Circuit Criminal Trial and Evidence Practice Pointers

Judge William H. Filmore, Tobie J. Smith, and J. Patrick Lamb Most Often Cited Rule of Evidence: 404(b) The first sentence of Alabama Rules of Evidence Rule 404(b) gives the general rule: “Evidence of other crimes, wrongs, or acts is not admissible to prove the character of a person in order to show action in conformity therewith.”

Continue ReadingCircuit Criminal Trial and Evidence Practice Pointers

Probate Court Evidentiary and Procedural Potential Pitfalls

By Judge William D. Motlow and R. Bradley Phillips There is a misconception among some attorneys that the Rules of Evidence do not apply during proceedings in the probate courts of this state. Rule 1101 of the Rules states the “rules of evidence apply in all proceedings in the courts of Alabama.”

Continue ReadingProbate Court Evidentiary and Procedural Potential Pitfalls

Evidence Rules and Trial Skills: Where Are We and Where Do We Go from Here

By Judge W. Scott Donaldson “The Constitution guarantees a fair trial through the Due Process Clauses...[A] fair trial is one in which evidence subject to adversarial testing is presented to an impartial tribunal for resolution of issues defined in advance of the proceeding.”

Continue ReadingEvidence Rules and Trial Skills: Where Are We and Where Do We Go from Here

A Brief History of Alabama Evidence Law and A Few Tips for the Alabama Lawyer

The Alabama Rules of Evidence did not become effective until January 1, 1996, nearly 200 years after the Alabama court system was created. For many decades, Alabama evidence law was found in the case law, statutes, and the constitutions of both Alabama and the United States

Continue ReadingA Brief History of Alabama Evidence Law and A Few Tips for the Alabama Lawyer